I came across this posting on LinkedIn today (1/9/11), by a connection of mine – Jennifer Rai. I would never question her sincerity. However, this quote just struck me as so misleading, I am prompted to write about it.
“Failure doesn’t mean you are a failure it just means you haven’t succeeded yet.” ~Robert H. Schuller
What little I know about Mr. Schuller, includes a large dose of noting his being well known as a positive thinker. He may think as positively as he may like, but this quote is simply not correct – he has blatantly ignored a generally accepted dictionary practice – words mean what they mean – it is not acceptable, reasonable, or logical to redefine them on a whim – however good that redefinition may seem at first reading.
This firstly reminds me of the salesmen treating each and every rejection where a prospective client rejected a sales pitch by saying no toward purchasing a product or service. Whatever the reason or means, the client is right – no means no. Get over it. Sales folk do get over it. In general they refuse to acknowledge that this no is both a personal, professional, and product oriented rejection. They rebound by distorting the facts that they haven’t succeeded yet. Great mental gymnastics, but a distortion of reality. A no is not the end of the world, but it is a failure.
I suppose that is why I am not in sales – I recognize failure all too well and easily. Rejection is real, especially when it is in the context of being primarily personal. It hurts, and frankly is meant to hurt by the perpetrators – rejection is acutely personal and deliberate. Yes, it is what is done next that is important – the key for me to recognize that a failure has occurred – and then move on. It is in the moving on where I connect, albeit in an exceptionally small and with greatly reserved manner with Mr. Schuller, with whom I definitely do not identify.
I wrote the following comment to Jennifer Rai:
Something is wrong here; we are ignoring the definitions for failure: 1. The condition or fact of not achieving the desired end or ends: the failure of an experiment. 2. One that fails: a failure at one’s career. Very common. 3. The condition or fact of being insufficient or falling short: a crop failure. 4. A cessation of proper functioning or performance: a power failure. 5. Nonperformance of what is requested or expected; omission: failure to report a change of address. 6. The act or fact of failing to pass a course, test, or assignment. 7. A decline in strength or effectiveness. 8. The act or fact of becoming bankrupt or insolvent.
Some elaborating remarks may be helpful:
- Experiments are excellent illustrations of failure. Experiments are exceptionally time, labor, and equipment intensive undertakings. In general, experiments fail much more frequently than they succeed. Even when they appear to succeed, ideally an independent repeat of the experiment may indicate the first success was a fluke. Due diligent and intellectual honesty are necessary to fully air the failure. Absence to air the failure may cause an exceptional waste of resources by others. I would suggest that airing failures be embraced by would be professionals.
- A career failure is a most common event. This may manifest as the death of a vision, all the way to clearly seeing incomplete, if indeed incompetent thinking. The earlier these are exposed as failures, the better off we all should be. As devastating as failures are, acknowledgment of them as failures clears the way for improvements. Furthermore, failures are not guaranteed precursors to success – they are singular events, but much must change if success is even feasible after a failure.
- Falling short, in truth is an exceptionally common condition. We all fall short. As noted above, what we do about this is most critical. Changes must accompany failure. Missing the mark is another synonym expression. I have tried bow and arrow in my youth – failure was a characteristic of that experience – yes, I missed the mark. And the target completely!
- I like the illustration of a power failure. We had a power failure during the summer of 2010 of the transformer in our electrical service entrance at home. The corrective action was removing and replacing the transformer.
- The next item addresses acts of commission or omission. The corrective action is to make the necessary and sufficient changes.
- School work is an immediate illustration in my thinking triggered by the next element of the definition. In my education, geography studies were not my strong suite. I started out well and then failed. That failure was a source of encouragement to me to have a life-long interest in such matters – most recently enjoying listening to presentations on travel, geography, history, culture, and language – to name a few. It was my weakness in geography that encouraged my continuing study of this subject. The starting point was recognition of that deficiency and my demonstrated incompetence.
- Decline in strength and effectiveness. One observation is physical strength decays with age. I have zero interest and ability today to run in track and field events nor run in cross-country meets. Yep, that is a failure, no problem. The fact that I used to be very good in those areas is of no consequence.
- The act or fact of becoming bankrupt or insolvent is a failure. Those of us in transition know and realize this very well. Toward that end, we recognized the imminent possibility of those conditions of failure and continue to exercise correct process to mitigate against same.
My conclusion is embrace failure, we are all failures, but do not become stuck in failure. Avoid mental gymnastics – failure is a common condition of life. Recognize same and move on – and, success in our own strength is not guaranteed by any means. We will all be better by and because of failure.